stemedb/.claude/skills/aphoria-self-review/checklists/persona-value.md

Persona Value Audit Checklist

Use this checklist during Phase 2 of the Self-Review SOP.

Persona Definitions

Developer Persona

Question: "What do I need to fix before commit?"

Useful claims:

• Security misconfigurations that block merge
• API contract violations
• Deprecated pattern usage
• Missing required validations

Noise claims:

• Informational metadata
• Correct defaults that don't need action
• Claims about unchanged code

Auditor Persona

Question: "What's the risk posture?"

Useful claims:

• Security-relevant configurations
• Compliance violations
• Trust boundary crossings
• Cryptographic choices

Noise claims:

• Non-security configurations
• Style/formatting observations
• Internal implementation details

ADK User Persona

Question: "What context should my agent see?"

Useful claims:

• API endpoints and contracts
• Authentication requirements
• Rate limits and quotas
• Error handling patterns

Noise claims:

• Internal implementation details
• Test-only configurations
• Build system metadata

SDET Persona

Question: "Are we testing the right things?"

Useful claims:

• Security-critical code paths
• External integrations
• Error conditions
• Configuration variations

Noise claims:

• Already-tested patterns
• Trivial configurations
• Generated code

Per-Persona Audit

Developer

Claim Type	Count	Classification	Rationale
		Useful / Noise
		Useful / Noise
		Useful / Noise

• Useful claims: ___
• Noise claims: ___
• Persona Value Score: ___ / ___ = ___
• Status: PASS (>= 0.70) / FAIL (< 0.70)

Auditor

Claim Type	Count	Classification	Rationale
		Useful / Noise
		Useful / Noise
		Useful / Noise

• Useful claims: ___
• Noise claims: ___
• Persona Value Score: ___ / ___ = ___
• Status: PASS (>= 0.70) / FAIL (< 0.70)

ADK User

Claim Type	Count	Classification	Rationale
		Useful / Noise
		Useful / Noise
		Useful / Noise

• Useful claims: ___
• Noise claims: ___
• Persona Value Score: ___ / ___ = ___
• Status: PASS (>= 0.70) / FAIL (< 0.70)

SDET

Claim Type	Count	Classification	Rationale
		Useful / Noise
		Useful / Noise
		Useful / Noise

• Useful claims: ___
• Noise claims: ___
• Persona Value Score: ___ / ___ = ___
• Status: PASS (>= 0.70) / FAIL (< 0.70)

Cross-Persona Analysis

Claims useful to multiple personas (high value):

• ---

Claims that are noise for ALL personas (should suppress):

• ---

Outcome

• Primary persona identified
• All four personas audited
• Scores calculated
• Failing personas identified for improvement