The 2026-08-20 livelock ran 21h with no page. TidalDBClusterReseedPending is
`tidaldb_cluster_reseed_required == 1 for 10m`, written for exactly this, but the
defect cleared the marker ~200ms after each latch, so the gauge flapped 1->0
every ~30s and never held 1 for 10m. Add TidalDBClusterReseedFlapping, which
keys off `changes(...[15m]) > 2` instead of a hold duration, so a latch/clear
loop pages even when the gauge reads 0 at both ends of the window and even if a
future clear path reintroduces the spurious clear.
Also add an on-call banner for the operator intervention now in force: the
client Service selector is narrowed to keep tidaldb-0 out of the read path,
because its shard-1 frontier was cross-seeded from shard 2's snapshot artifact
and its reads are untrustworthy even at lag_events: 0. The banner carries the
footgun (the label is on the pods, not the template, so it does not survive pod
recreation) plus repair and revert commands.
`cargo test --workspace` could not run at all: dependency resolution failed with
"aws-types@1.3.16 requires rustc 1.91.1" on the 1.91.0 default toolchain, so the
gate the project documents was dead. Making it run exposed a compile break and
two wrong tests that had been invisible for months. Now green end to end:
143 suites, 3155 tests, exit 0.
Toolchain
- rust-toolchain.toml pins the DEV toolchain to 1.91.1. The published MSRV stays
`rust-version = "1.91"` (the engine builds on 1.91.0); only tidalctl's AWS SDK
chain needs the patch release, and it now declares that itself.
Consumer crates migrated to the current engine API (clean cutover)
- iknowyou-engine: `AgentPolicy` gained five m10 read/profile-override fields;
the literal now spreads `..AgentPolicy::default()` as the engine's own doc
example does, so future fields do not break it again.
- forage-engine: `RetrieveResult` gained p1 `reasons`. The app builds its own
candidate pool, so it now tags what it knows: PreferenceMatch for the
preference-vector blend, SemanticMatch (with the seed item) for
similar-to-saved, ExplorationBudget for pinned discoveries.
- forage-engine: `url_to_item_id` folded into the u32 item universe. The engine
narrows item IDs to a u32 slot in durable per-user state and rejects anything
above u32::MAX rather than alias two items forever, so every add_item with a
64-bit FNV hash failed. 9 of 28 smoke tests were failing on this alone.
- forage-engine: bridge items read the top-2 preference CLUSTERS via
`query_vectors`, not the single centroid from `preference_vectors().get()`.
Since m12 that accessor returns only the strongest cluster, so a tech+jazz user
whose interests split into two clusters looked single-interest and never
bridged. Falls back to top-2 dimensions when a user has one cluster.
Reconcile tests corrected to the shipped contract
- tidal/tests/m8p3_reconcile_production.rs asserted `3 + 5 == 8` for a windowed
count after heal. `take_crdt_snapshot` deliberately keys signal contributions
to ONE canonical contributor (ShardId::SINGLE) because signals are relayed from
a single writer, so per-node attribution double-counted every replicated event
on every reconcile. Merge is therefore LWW on (last_update_ns, score) plus
PN-counter per-node max: nodes converge on the more complete accumulator. The
old expectation was asserting the bug that fix removed.
- Rewrote to assert convergence, count survival (not 0), and no inflation, and
added `repeated_reconcile_of_converged_nodes_does_not_creep` - the regression
guard for the creep itself, which nothing covered.
Pre-commit hook unified
- hooks/pre-commit dropped `-D warnings`: each crate's `[lints]` table is the
source of truth (`clippy::all`/`unwrap_used` deny, `pedantic` warn), and the
flag promoted ~58 deliberate pedantic warnings in integration tests to errors,
making every Rust commit impossible.
- It now lints all five tidal crates instead of path-matching `tidal/`, which
silently skipped tidal-server, tidal-net, tidal-stress, tidalctl and
applications/ - the rot above lived in exactly those crates. Ported the
CODING_GUIDELINES file-length, println, and unsafe-SAFETY checks from the
divergent untracked copy that this replaces.
- CONTRIBUTING.md now documents the real commands and the toolchain/MSRV split.
Fleet recovery and soak
- scripts/restore-fleet.sh: the fail-closed selective restore, promoted out of an
ignored tmp/ directory into the repository. Preflights retained storage,
digest-pinned images, parked state, and aggregate plus per-PV-node scheduler
headroom before the first scale; writes a durable transcript under
tmp/restore-logs/ with structured start/error/rollback/complete events.
- k8s manifests park the standalone store, the RF3 cluster, and the soak monitor
at zero replicas with restore-fleet.sh as the only supported scale-up path.
- soak-eval/soak-watch and the nightly CronJob fail closed on stale or missing
restart evidence instead of silently skipping the restart-aware half of the gate.
- docs/ops/capacity-planning.md corrects the RAM envelope to the real hot-tier
formula and separates analytic totals from the measured process envelope.
The runbooks had drifted to the retired m8/m11p5 design while all m12 production
reality (topology, perf, fixes, DR) sat only in a profiling doc no operator opens.
This promotes that reality into the runbooks and fixes the contradictions.
Contradictions fixed:
- runbooks/cluster.md: the "NEITHER IS QUORUM-ACKED HA YET" status banner was FALSE
(quorum-ack + automatic election have been live since m11p3/p4). Rewritten to
state the deployed reality (single-StatefulSet full-placement RF3, rc7).
- README.md: the cluster section called the HA cluster a "built-in simulated
cluster / multi-region fabric" demo and showed promote-by-region as failover.
Rewritten — real quorum HA, automatic failover, /cluster/promote is a maintenance
verb. Kept the honest caveats (experimental gate, global-signals-only).
Reality promoted into the runbooks:
- Live topology (single STS, ns tidaldb-cluster, 3 voters, full-placement RF3,
gRPC 9601/9602/9603, HTTPS+mTLS :9500), the five shipped fixes, and the real
build+digest-pin procedure (cross-compile -> trixie -> amd64 PLATFORM manifest,
not the index/attestation digest) in cluster.md + kubernetes.md.
- Stale constants: soak ramp 3900 -> 200 rps; cluster grace 60 -> 600s; the
pre-m12 4.5k/s signal-write perf table annotated + the 1536-D read reality added.
- ops/capacity-planning.md: new "Ref-A 3-node fleet — measured capacity" section
(read p99/ceiling, ~250 rps write knee, 1M needs >16GiB nodes, pod resources).
- ops/recovery.md: new cluster-recovery routing section + scoped the quiesce-and-
copy note to standalone (the cluster uses tidalctl + the DR runbook).
New docs:
- runbooks/disaster-recovery.md: the proven S3/R2 backup -> restore -> byte-verify
-> query-proof procedure, full-cluster rebuild, PITR posture (previously
undocumented despite being proven against real S3).
- runbooks/on-call.md: incident response — symptom -> golden signal -> runbook,
severity, escalation, and the open alert-wiring step.
- runbooks/README.md: the runbook index + current production facts.
Open follow-up (infra, not docs): ops/prometheus-alerts.yaml is accurate but
design-reference; promoting it to a live PrometheusRule is the one unwired step.
Switched content_vector to 1536-dim (text-embedding-3-small, thepeach production
width) and ran the realistic peach mix (feed-profile reads + signal writes) on the
m11p6 mTLS cluster.
Result: 1536-dim costs ~nothing on throughput vs 128-dim — knee still ~2,976 rps
(128-dim was 2,981). The write bottleneck is quorum-commit on the 2-worker leader
pool, not vector size. The vector READ path (feed-profile retrieve — the
db.retrieve(profile) path thepeach E2/R8 calls) stays p99 3-11ms through 1500 rps,
never the bottleneck. Memory is the only dim-sensitive resource (567-751 MiB/pod
at 20k items, ~12x 128-dim) — capacity-plan RAM, not throughput.
Recommended sustained target: <=1,000 signal-ingest rps (~1,200 full mix) — 40% of
knee, 2.5x headroom, survives single-node failover, write p99 ~45ms within SLA.
Also: fixed the stale "deployed schema is 128" note in tidal-stress (now reflects
the configurable width). Full writeup: docs/ops/benchmark-1536-peach.md.
Kind-3 term markers in the WAL stream, STREAM-relative vote frontiers,
heartbeat-only divergence detection + quarantine, and fenced promote.
Elections converge in 0.6–1.0s; zero acked-write loss across all kill points.
Closes G5 (leaderless recovery) from the v0.9 wave.
WAL segment format: 8-byte TSEG header (magic + version byte + 3 reserved)
prepended to every new segment. Legacy headerless segments (m0-m11p3) read
as implicit v0 — no migration. Unknown magic/version surfaces as
WalError::SegmentFormatUnknown at open time; foreign files are never
repaired or truncated (fixes the silent data-loss path from the p3 rollout
incident where torn-tail repair zeroed a follower's unreadable segments).
Catch-up transport: FAILED_PRECONDITION ("snapshot required") and stream
errors that skip the shard now arm a timer retry (re-arm-on-skip is the
load-bearing liveness fix — without it a skipped pull never re-fires and
the follower stays permanently behind). Single retry pending per shard;
CatchupRunner owns the Arc'd state shared between the retry tasks and the
transport. Test: tidal-net/tests/catchup_retry.rs covers the retry path.
Stress: k8s stress-job-t2a/t2b yaml + ops/stress-test-p3-t2 runbook.
ack=quorum gates replicated writes on a majority of the replica set durably
holding them: followers push their durably-applied frontier (ReportApplied,
once per apply round, decoupled from ship acks), the leader folds frontier
reports + ship-ack hints + heal resumes into a leadership-scoped CommitIndex
(k-th-largest durable mark), and handlers await it through an async
watch-channel bridge (zero parked threads per waiter). Honest timeouts:
retryable 503 naming the laggards; x-tidal-seq on every cluster write.
Follower blob applies are batched under group-commit fsyncs (22x seeding).
Exit gate: 167/167 leader-SIGKILL kill points, zero acked-write loss.
Seven-dimension review pass (all confirmed findings fixed):
- WAL blob drain now ABORTS on the first write failure instead of reusing
the failed seqno mid-drain (a torn record buried mid-segment would
truncate every later acked record on replay)
- apply_replicated_blobs waits every staged append even after a mid-batch
failure, parses metadata once, and moves records into Arcs shared with
the WAL writer (no deep clone per record on the follower apply path)
- CommitIndex: zero-peer fast path now respects demotion (active checked
under lock before the single-replica return), k-th-largest uses
select_nth over a reused scratch buffer
- await_quorum: re-reads the index once after the deadline fires (no false
503 for a write that committed in the race window), warns when the
commit-watch bridge dies outside shutdown, zero-peer path checks active
- notify_applied report failures: WARN on the first failure of a streak,
INFO on recovery (a silently stalling frontier reads as unexplained
quorum 503s); receiver skips re-notifying unadvanced frontiers
- x-tidal-deduplicated: 1 marks dedup-suppressed signal writes (relayed
through forwards) so durability cursors can tell dedup from no-seqno
- docs: 167/167 kill-point record corrected in CHANGELOG; rolling-upgrade
order (leader first — a pre-m11p3 leader silently downgrades quorum
requests to leader-ack) in CHANGELOG + runbook §8; monitoring note for
report-loss diagnosis on the quorum-timeout alert
Verified: workspace clippy -D warnings (incl. cluster-e2e targets), full
tidaldb/tidal-net/tidal-server/tidalctl suites green, tier-3 multi-process
quorum suite green (8/8 kill points, zero acked loss, partition gate/recover).
m11p1 — decoupled ack/ship path: staged writes (seqno+WAL+relay-push,
microseconds) separate from group-commit fsync; ShipQueue batches+windows
outbound segments; receiver coalesces inbound chunks before applying.
Adds first tidaldb_cluster_* metrics.
m11p2 — leader WAL is now THE replicated log: fsynced batches feed a
bounded WalShipFeed and ship byte-identical to followers; WAL seqnos
survive restarts (relay-reset hazard gone). Item metadata and embeddings
journal kind-1/2 blob records on the same stream as signals; the m8p10
HTTP broadcast is deleted. StreamSegments catch-up is follower-pulled via
server-streaming RPC, triggered on gap detection, follower boot, and
leader heal nudge. Promote carries a stream baseline so peers skip
pre-stream history.
New workspace crate: an open-loop, coordinated-omission-corrected HTTP load
generator + capacity ramp for the standalone and multi-process cluster surfaces,
modeling a thepeach feed session (feed reads + view/like/skip signals + search,
signal-dominated per their user-graph spec). Throttleable target rate, ramp
presets (smoke/quick/peach-100k/max) or rps:secs specs, peach/reads/writes/custom
mixes, leader vs sharded write paths, per-op p50/p90/p99/p999/max latency, a
backpressure-aware status breakdown (429/408/503/4xx/5xx/transport), and a verdict
translated to supported DAU. Runs in-cluster as a k8s Job (tidal-stress/k8s/).
Open-loop scheduler (scheduler.rs) fires at a fixed arrival rate and measures
latency from each request's intended send time, so a server stall inflates the
percentiles a closed-loop test hides; it shed-and-counts rather than blocking when
the in-flight cap is reached. Pure-Rust (tokio + reqwest/rustls), no engine deps.
Findings on the live 3-region k3s cluster (docs/ops/stress-test-thepeach.md):
reads scale to thousands/s at <15ms p99; the replicated /signals path saturates at
~90 signals/s (single-leader funnel + 2-worker write pool + synchronous gRPC ship);
the sharded path sustains 3,669 signals/s at 0 errors and ~27% cluster CPU (≈ the
100k-DAU peak, knee not reached). Overload degrades gracefully (429; 0 pod
restarts). thepeach's planned in-process embedding sidesteps all of it (write ≈82ns).
Splits monolithic cluster.rs into tidal-server/src/cluster/ modules. Adds redeliver-missed
relay, bounded HLC drift, lag tracking, and reconcile idempotence. Five new tier-3 test suites
(chaos, lifecycle, multiproc, region, routes, runbook) all green. Docs, CHANGELOG, and ROADMAP
updated with G4/G5/G6 known gaps.
- Eliminate the tidal/ self-contained doc mirror; docs now have two canonical
homes (root *.md and docs/), with planning/specs/research/reviews moved up
- Remove stale .agents/skills and .ai mirrors; canonicalize skills under .claude/
- Add pre-commit hook + scripts/check-docs.sh doc-guard + scripts/install-hooks.sh
- Implement M0-M10 seven-dimension review findings across engine, net, server,
and tidalctl (durability, replication, query, WAL, storage, CLI hardening)
